Instructions for refrees

The following information will be helpful when preparing your report:

1- Please complete the manuscript evaluation form completely.

2- Is this paper scientifically rigorous, accurate and correct?

3- Is the work relevant and novel and does it add significantly to results that are already published?

4- What impact do you think this paper will have in the field?

5- Has the author made reference to the most recent and most appropriate work?

6- Is the title adequate and appropriate?

7- Is the paper well written and the work clearly communicated?

8- Does the abstract contain the essential information about the paper?

9- Are figures and tables clear and essential, and captions informative?

10- Does the paper contain a carefully written conclusion, summarising what has been learned and why it is interesting and useful?